Toys & Figures

Collectibles Became the Toy Industry: Reading Circana's 20 Percent Year

Collectibles Became the Toy Industry: Reading Circana's 20 Percent Year
November 13, 2026Collectap Editorial

Circana released its January through September figures for the US toy market on November 12, and the top line reads like a typo: dollar sales up 20 percent against the same nine months of 2025. Unit sales up 18 percent. Average selling price up only 2 percent.

That last number is the one worth sitting with. When a market grows 20 percent in dollars on 18 percent more units, the growth is not coming from price increases. People bought substantially more stuff. In a year that opened with tariff anxiety and a steady drumbeat of surcharge notices from manufacturers, that is not the outcome most of the trade expected.

For collectors, though, the headline is almost beside the point. The useful information is in the breakdown underneath it, because the categories that carried 2026 are the ones we were already standing in front of.

Where the growth actually came from

Ten of Circana's eleven toy supercategories grew in dollars through September, and eight of those also grew in units. The leaders:

  • Explorative and Other Toys: up 75 percent, led by sports cards. This is the fastest growing slice of the entire US toy market, and it is effectively the trading card aisle wearing a toy-industry label.
  • Games and Puzzles: up 45 percent, driven by trading cards, with Circana calling out Pokemon and Magic: The Gathering by name.
  • Arts and Crafts: up 23 percent, boosted by slime-making kits.
  • Building Sets: up 17 percent, with the LEGO Botanical Collection singled out as a driver.

The declines, meanwhile, landed almost entirely in outdoor, active, and seasonal play. Pools, ride-ons, sand toys, bikes. The parts of the store that have nothing to do with anything you keep on a shelf.

Two numbers cut across all of those categories and matter more than any single one of them. Collectible toy sales grew 56 percent. Licensed toys grew 27 percent, and licensed product now accounts for well over a third of US toys sold.

Put plainly: the toy industry had its best year in roughly a decade, and the collector aisle paid for it.

The aisle is being built for adults now

Circana says consumers aged 12 and older accounted for the majority of the industry's growth through September, and that collectible growth specifically was led by adult demographics. Earlier in the year, the same firm had adults 18 and over driving roughly 35 percent of all US toy growth through April. The trend did not soften over the summer. It accelerated.

Kristen McLean, Vice President of Client Insights in Circana's Entertainment Knowledge Group, framed it as a shift in behavior rather than a demographic quirk, noting that consumers increasingly collect, display, and use toys to express personal interests rather than treating them strictly as children's products.

Anyone who has waited in a midnight line for a figure drop already knew that. What is new is that the number is now large enough to steer product planning. When a buyer at a national chain sees 56 percent growth in collectibles and a decline in sand toys, next year's planogram writes itself. Expect more shelf space for premium figures, more adult-targeted building sets, more card product at the front of the store, and fewer of the broad kid-general SKUs that used to fill the middle.

That is good news for selection and bad news for calm. The same data that gets you a bigger figure aisle also tells manufacturers that collectors will absorb a higher price point and a tighter print run.

Pokemon is the weather, not a storm

Pokemon remained the industry's single top property through September and one of its fastest growing. Not the top trading card property. The top toy property, outright, across an industry that includes LEGO, Barbie, Hot Wheels, and every licensed movie line on the shelf.

That has a practical consequence for anyone who collects something else. When one franchise is both the biggest and among the fastest growing, it bends everything around it: retail shelf allocation, distributor priorities, grading queue times, even shipping supply during heavy release weeks. If you collect sports cards, One Piece, Magic, or figures, you are competing for the same retail floor space and the same fulfillment capacity as a franchise printing at historic volume.

Sports properties are the other force here. Circana flagged significant gains for products tied to World Soccer, MLB, and NFL franchises, which tracks with a World Cup year and a trading card category that has been compounding for several years.

The fourth largest toy retailer is a video feed

The most structurally interesting figure in the report has nothing to do with any product category. TikTok Shop toy sales nearly tripled this year to 1.6 billion dollars, making it the fourth largest toy retailer in the United States and roughly 5 percent of all toy sales. Circana also notes that nearly half of consumers report buying something after seeing it on social media.

If you have been collecting for more than a couple of years, you have watched this happen in real time: the breaking channels, the live rip shows, the mystery box sellers, the resellers who move an entire case through a two-hour stream. What the report confirms is that this is no longer a side channel. It is a top-four retailer, with the allocation leverage that implies.

Two things follow. First, a meaningful share of product now enters the market through sellers whose inventory never touches a shelf you can walk up to, which is part of why in-store restocks feel thinner than the production numbers suggest. Second, price discovery has moved. A figure or a sealed box can get bid up in a live room hours before it shows on any sales-history chart you consult, which makes stale comps more dangerous than they were two years ago.

The new impulse tier

One more pattern worth noting, because it will be all over the shelf in December. Tactile and sensory toys generated 671 million dollars through September, about six times the prior year's level. Keychain sales are up more than 200 percent year to date.

This is the small-format collectible tier maturing: plush charms, blind-bag keychains, squishies, bag clips. Low unit price, high repeat purchase, heavy social visibility. For collectors, this is where the next wave of chase variants and limited colorways will show up, and where the gap between 4 dollar retail and 40 dollar secondary prices tends to open fastest.

What this changes for the next six weeks

Circana expects collectibles, licensed merchandise, building sets, sports products, arts and crafts, and fandom-driven toys to be among the strongest performers this holiday. Translate that into shopping behavior:

Treat December restocks as the last clean window of the year. Manufacturers reading a 20 percent year will not be over-producing into Q1. Lines that have been available all autumn are the ones most likely to quietly disappear in February.

Stop using autumn comps on card product. With Games and Puzzles up 45 percent and Explorative up 75 percent, sealed pricing has been moving under you. Check a sale date before you anchor on a number.

Watch the small-format tier before it gets expensive. Keychains and plush charms are following the same curve blind boxes did three years ago. The cheap entry point is now.

Be skeptical of live-room urgency. A top-four retailer that runs on video feeds is very good at manufacturing a deadline. The product is usually still there an hour later.

Buy the thing, not the trend line. A 56 percent category increase is not a promise about any individual figure, set, or sealed box. It is a statement about aggregate demand, and aggregate demand does not pay your shipping.

Key Takeaways

  • US toy dollar sales rose 20 percent through September, on 18 percent more units, so this was volume growth rather than price inflation.
  • Collectible toys grew 56 percent and licensed toys 27 percent; sports cards and trading cards drove the two fastest growing supercategories at 75 and 45 percent.
  • Consumers aged 12 and up accounted for most of the industry's growth, and adults led collectible growth specifically.
  • Pokemon is the top property in the entire US toy industry, which shapes shelf space and fulfillment capacity for everything else.
  • TikTok Shop nearly tripled to 1.6 billion dollars and is now the fourth largest US toy retailer, which has moved price discovery into live video.
  • Expect tighter Q1 availability on anything that sold through this autumn, and expect manufacturers to price accordingly.

Prices and figures in this article are estimates drawn from published reporting and move quickly. Verify current market values before buying or selling.

toy-collectingmarket-reporttrading-cardscollecting-strategy
Back to Blog